Pop the champagne, kids... not only do we no longer have to witness
the brain dead Jason Castro make a fool out of himself and the show,
BUT we got Bice back. Some things never change...Archuleta's ability
to constantly make humility annoying... and Bo's ability to channel
Jesus, all the while making love to his vocoder. What is going on
with this show?? Let's not brush aside the fact that we just watched
Adam Levine of Maroon 5 go thru puberty on stage (does he have any
bass at all in his voice?). i mean it's one thing to be in touch with
your feminine side, but come on, there's a limit.

So we're left with 3 less than compelling contestants. That said, it
makes more sense each week why David Cook should win this. He is the
ONLY one doing anything original and unique. Period.

Because the stars aligned tonight and my wish was granted, I will keep
watching. See you back here next week.

Analyzing Your Idols,
Mattie Walsh

ps...did anyone actually watch the "I Shot the Sheriff" encore??? If
so, I'm fascinated and I want to talk to you.